A Rare Encounter at Sea

On July 21, 2005 while flying a mission to locate and tag basking sharks for the Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries east of Cape Cod, I reported to Captain Bill Chaprales and Dr. Greg Skomal aboard the fishing vessel EZYDUZIT the location of a group of sharks in the vicinity of the BC buoy. With the boat more than a half hour steam from that location, I decided to fly south to determine if there were any more sharks in that area. I came upon a solitary, healthy young northern right whale and began to photograph it for identification purposes. Right whales are a critically endangered species, with only 300-350 individuals known to exist. They are monitored carefully and to identify and pinpoint the location of any animal is important information for right whale researchers. As I shot photos and simultaneously scanned the horizon for other signs of life, I spotted an unusually large spot of white water 5 miles away and, being the curious sort, flew that way to investigate. What I found there was a most unusual grouping of 4 adult right whales, which were literally piling on top of each other at the surface. 


select photo for greater detail

Being very social animals, it is not unusual for right whales to be seen in tight groups like this during mating season, which is mostly during the winter months, or in pairs courting one another. But this was mid-summer and these animals were clearly agitated. As I began to photograph the group for the usual ID shots, an extra boil, then a flash of black beneath the whales caught my eye. Assuming that this was a group of pilot whales playing with them and always looking for photographs of animals interacting with each other, I drew back and began to shoot. A sudden flash of white, then another told me instantly that these were not pilot whales, but orcas…..killer whales to most. Sure enough, as the airplane came around and the glare on the water cleared, there they were….a swarm of 10-11 adults and juveniles surrounding the right whales. I immediately informed Capt. Chaprales of the situation, knowing that this was a very special event, and that he would have to forego the shark tagging for a while in order for me to document this. It is always a treat to observe and document endangered right whales. Killer whales are documented in the Gulf of Maine and adjacent waters only once in every 5-10 years. Many fishermen and researchers have spent their entire lives at sea and never seen them. I had only seen them once, a female and her calf in Cape Cod Bay in the late 70's. To see the 2 species together was indeed a special moment. 


select photo for greater detail

The killer whales initially made several passes beneath and close behind the right whales in what appeared to be a coordinated attempt to separate the right whales. Led primarily by 2 large males and 4 smaller adults, presumably females and younger males, they repeated this process several times as the right whales slapped their tales and accelerated in a westerly direction, all the while pressing against one another. 


select photo for greater detail

The killer whales that so rarely pass through our waters are thought to be primarily fish eaters, feeding on bluefin tuna and other species, though this cannot be known with any degree of certainty, for so little is known about them. It is questionable whether killer whales could take down a healthy adult right whale. Though appearing to be very awkward, docile animals, right whales are extremely agile, powerful, and very "handy" with there large tale flukes. There is evidence in the form of scarring and missing appendages, however, that killer whales will attack juvenile right whales, as they do humpbacks from time to time.


select photo for greater detail

Each time the killer whales drew near, the right whales pulled together, there massive heads butting and pushing into one another in what appeared to be a defensive posture. From time to time the killer whales would separate themselves briefly from the right whales and eventually the smaller animals remained at a distance while the more aggressive adults continued to harass. Though still very agitated and traveling at a fast clip on the surface, the 4 right whales would relax somewhat during those brief moments, but return to the tight defensive posture with each pass of the 6 remaining aggressors. In the end, after one half hour of observing and photographing this event, it appeared that the killer whales were riding the "bow wake" of the right whales in a more playful posture, much like dolphins with a boat or with other whales. Though they continued to "buzz" the larger animals from time to time, as if knowing how obnoxious they were to the much larger right whales, it appeared that an attack was not imminent.


select photo for greater detail

In the end, duty called and I was called to return to the tagging of basking sharks. Reluctantly, I left this scene knowing that I had witnessed something that perhaps no one had seen before, but with eager anticipation of my photographic results and sharing this moment with others.

Tim Voorheis

Gulf of Maine Productions
70 East Falmouth Hwy., Suite 3  •  East Falmouth, MA 02536
Contact: Christian Valle • Tel: (508) 548-1450 ext. 11   •  Fax: (508) 548-1950
Email: info@gulfofmaineproductions.org

All photos, text, design, logos and content on this website are not to be copied,
downloaded or recreated in any-way without permission from Gulf of Maine Productions. 

2008 all rights reserved